And, here are action ideas 7-10.
Please consider these action ideas, many of which you may already be practicing, and resolve with me to make our circles at church more open, more generous, and more holy.
If they seem obvious to you: great! You're probably already doing these things! If they seem suspect or like overkill to you, maybe examine why.
TL;DR:
7) Don't ever make it about me.
8) Avoid asking personal questions rooted in stereotypes.
9) Listen, learn, and become friends.
10) Repent.
7) "And be ye kind one to another, tenderhearted"
See also: mourn with those that mourn, in previous post.
Stock image
Eeeeeek, this is a tricky one. Ever hear of White Tears? You probably have. (Either way, I recommend
About the Weary Weaponizing of White Women's Tears by Luvvie Ajayi Jones and
White Women's Tears and the Men Who Love Them by Robin DiAngelo.) "White Tears" don't mean a white person's natural
empathetic human tears. White Tears are a emotional tool to help me center a situation around
myself. There are a whole lot of tears flowing at church, and there always were and there always will be. So where is the line?
Action: If I find myself in an uncomfortable or emotional situation with a person of another race--or I am
talking about race at church, for instance trying to stand up for someone who is a victim of racism, or maybe I'm bearing my testimony or it's some other emotionally charged moment--and I need to cry, because crying happens,
I will make sure my tears are not about me. If they are about me, and I can't redirect the emotion to focus on what the problem really is, then I will excuse myself until I'm ready.
I *think* I can avoid this situation by processing those types of tears on my own at home so they don't sneak up on me in public. If I'm accused of being racist and I feel tears coming, I will promptly apologize--"I am so sorry that I hurt you, and I will listen if you'd like to say anything further"--and then promise to get back to the person ASAP once I've composed myself.
I am not talking about empathetic tears in an intimate and loving conversation. I am talking about self-centering tears.
8) "In much patience, in afflictions, in necessities, in distresses, in stripes, in imprisonments, in tumults, in labours, in watchings, in fastings; by pureness, by knowledge, by longsuffering, by kindness, by the Holy Ghost, by love unfeigned, by the word of truth, by the power of God"
Whew, this discipleship thing is harder than it looks.
Stock image
Action: You might want to laugh at this one because it sounds so ridiculous, but it's really very unfunny. One way to help scale back the inadvertent offensive questions, and simultaneously to check our own biases, sounds really obvious and more than a little nerdy. If you have a question about Black people: before asking a Black person directly, try googling it first. Really. Have you ever asked a Black person if they wear sunscreen? I'm reluctant to admit that I did once.
I had never thought about it before. I knew about melanin but apparently not very much. We were at the pool and I offered this friend some of my sunscreen: "...or actually, do you wear sunscreen?" His answer was friendly and succinct: "Yes, I wear sunscreen." That was about 4 years ago. Ugh. I am a curious and open person, and I sometimes can get over-personal with people. But I am trying, and I think (?) I'm less likely to ask those questions now than I was 4 years ago.
You're probably better versed in human biology than I was at the time... at age 33... (
hmmm) so anyway, you won't run into that one. But what other weird ideas or questions might any well-intentioned person be harboring? Do they border on stereotypes? If a question about Black people (or Asian people or Latinx people or any people as a "people") pops up in my mind, if there's anything I'm wondering, try googling it before asking anyone. And then if I'm surprised by the answer, examine why. Dig into that.
While I'm googling, maybe even google around to figure out if I'm saying stuff I shouldn't be saying. (I literally just googled "what not to say to Black people" to see what's there, and a ton of articles popped up. Clearly a lot of people are wondering this...
or a lot of people are wishing that people were wondering this.) Note: This applies to any race I do not belong to.
Besides. After stocking up on all of that information, and digging the biases out of myself, I may just find that I can have a normal conversation about normal stuff and not be an idiot who is accidentally offensive. Please note: I am NOT an antiracism expert, if you want to be academic about it there are lots of classes and seminars and things to help with this type of idiocy which enough of us want to overcome including me, that it's a problem and there's a market for it, and an extra great thing about purchasing these services is that it is supporting Black-owned businesses. A few courses that I have seen that look great are run by
Dr. Mica McGriggs,
Dr. Lucretia Carter Berry, and
Monique Melton.
Side note about this. Sometimes people ask me a personal question about a "label" I belong to that they do not belong to--such as Latter-day Saint, or stay-at-home mom, or white person--and they preface it with "I don't want to be offensive," and I always laugh because I am a ridiculously open book, there are almost no questions you could ask me that would offend me
(except maybe if you catch me between day 22-28 of my cycle, and that is a stereotype that is very true in my case).
That confidence and openness comes from privilege. It comes from the fact that most days, people don't ask me naive questions about my race, because they know a lot about my race, because it's the dominant race in America. Also, I am unafraid of just about anyone who is asking me these questions. I know that "privilege" is a buzzword that has been around a long time, and sometimes it feels political or like an excuse, but it makes so much sense. I love
Jasmine Bradshaw's explorations of it at First Name Basis. Anyway, just wanted to note that just because I don't think anyone could offend me, doesn't mean I should ever assume that
my questions are inoffensive.
9) "Let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath"
Feel free to let me know if you've mastered this one. I like to talk and I'm usually right. Right?? ;)
Stock image
We've just established that just because I'm not easily offended doesn't mean I should assume that what I say is always inoffensive. Now about being swift to hear: listening instead of talking is so hard sometimes but so important. As far as action goes, number one is always going to be personal relationships, and we will all work on those in our own spheres. But we don't know everyone. And if we're a white Mormon, it's fairly likely that we aren't close with very many Black Mormons. Below I will share a few Black LDS people's perspectives that are available on the Internet, that I have found helpful.
Action: I will actively seek to listen to Black LDS people's perspectives (in all their varieties :) and to be a friend. Everyone makes friends in their own ways, but a few would be invite them over to dinner (someday when we're visiting each other's houses again...), make plans based on mutual interests, follow them on social media. You know, the usual. So: this action will be in my personal circle as well as voices that I connect with online, that I will continue to listen to, not just as a passing fad.
Obviously this doesn't mean cornering the next Black person and saying "Hello, please tell me your story of being Black at church!!!"
[cringe] It means becoming friends; learning about each other is part of that.
PSA: With the below links, I am including specifically people I am familiar with who talk about the Black LDS experience. There are also many many many MANY Black people of many faiths who have made their voices available online to listen to, enjoy, and learn from. Feel free to share any suggestions you have.
Black LDS Legacy and
Black Lives Matter to Christ (see previous post)
Beyond the Block: Every week these two discuss the Come Follow Me curriculum. In their own words: "Brother Jones and Brother Knox describe themselves as staunch advocates for the theology and harsh critics of the culture when it comes to Mormonism. A black life-long member and queer convert respectively, they bring a less heard perspective to the notoriously white and heteronormative faith."
First Name Basis: Look for Jasmine of First Name Basis on Instagram or any podcast app. She is Black biracial and a Latter-day Saint. "I'm Jasmine Bradshaw, a researcher, educator, podcaster, and founder of the First Name Basis Community. I truly believe that creating a more loving, inclusive, and just society starts within the sacred walls of our homes. First Name Basis exists to give you the tools you need to teach your children about race, religion, and culture. In this space we prioritize truth, hold one another accountable, and celebrate growth!"
Sistas in Zion: Tamu Smith and Zandra Vranes are on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook, and they have written multiple books together. "The Sistas in Zion are two friends, Zandra Vranes and Tamu Smith, who started a blog to keep in touch when one moved out of state. Their journey, detailed in their blog, touches on all aspects of life, but most especially and most importantly on being inclusive in a world that is increasingly polarizing and divisive."
*Bonus: Not LDS, but faith-based:
Black Coffee with White Friends: Marcie is a generous and faithful Black person who shares her perspective purposefully with thousands of white friends. "I am usually the only black person in the room. That is what this is, what this blog is all about: me being the only one, most days, in most of the places I go.... Unknowingly, we so often narrow our scope of black and of white. So therefore, we narrow our experience of the complexities of each color. We miss the nuances because we can't see the differing hues. These stories I hope widen our lenses. My days radiate a unique color of the Imago Dei reflecting a particular shade and hue that He specifically chose for me to wear, and said that it was 'Good.'"
10) "When we undertake to cover our sins, or to gratify our pride... the Spirit of the Lord is grieved"
Pretty strong language that speaks for itself.
Image via me
I saved the best for last! JK. This is complicated. Not all members of our Church, believing or not, have been happy with our leadership's tentative stance on our racist past. I'm personally not that happy with it, although I think I understand where it's coming from. The NAACP is maybe
medium happy with it. But I think I look at this through a specific lens, which is that I am faithful and have already spent many years reconciling a lot of the tough stuff. So it's easy to say to myself: this is a mess, but it's been a mess more often than not, and we still have a prophet, and we still have lots of people who are speaking up and staying faithful, and it is all going to be OK.
Jumping straight into the tough stuff all at once without a friend to lean on, though, can lead to a devastating faith crisis. If you're old enough, you may have already been through a faith crisis or two, and having friends to lean on can make the difference. Regardless, we have all been called to repentance lots of times, not just in D&C 121 (above) but also pretty recently, about this very topic.
Action: Daily, a little at a time, with the glimpses of clarity I can see as I'm trying my best, I will do what President Nelson has said: "The Creator of us all calls on each of us to abandon attitudes of prejudice against any group of God’s children. Any of us who has prejudice toward another race needs to repent!" How does a person repent of their sins? Something along the lines of: "confess them and forsake them." Also, repentance is not a quick or easy fix. It's a rebuilding.
Am I going to publicly self-flagellate so everyone knows
I ONCE WAS LOST, BUT NOW AM FOUND?
No.
Besides, in LDS theology, repentance is not a one-time thing. It is daily and it is personal. I will examine my past and present actions. I will do the work in whatever way makes sense to my heart. I will keep coming back. I will not stop.
Bonus scriptures and links listed in next post.
Series:
Part 1: Unspotted from the world
Part 2: Seek ye diligently
Part 3: Mourn with those that mourn
Part 4: In much patience
Part 5: "Come here" and "go there"