Monday, April 11, 2011

A parallel...if you will.

Five years ago I ran my first and only half marathon. 13.1 miles, that's the farthest I've run at one time. Actually I walked several times throughout and almost the entire 13th mile so I can't even say I ran the whole thing. After I staggered past the finish line I gratefully accepted some water, greeted my family who had all finished long before me, then dry-heaved for about 5 minutes in some bushes. I spent the rest of the day lying down whenever possible.

Running long distances: not really for me. At least, I haven't found the right combination of motivation, desire, and ability. (And I did train for that race...at least I think I did.) I have rarely experienced a runner's high and I definitely didn't in that race. Since then I have never run faster than a 9:00 mile. Usually more like 12:00. So I would rather not completely torture myself in a marathon basically just to say I had.

I have been at the finish line of lots of races, mostly my dad's marathons. That is an electric experience. My dad, who is 66, decided in his late 50s to start running marathons and hasn't stopped. I just can't identify with that kind of drive, but I get excited for my dad every time he completes one, especially when he beats his own PRs and feels great afterward. Anyone who crosses a marathon finish line has put in some serious work and is likely pretty proud of himself or herself.

I think many of my fellow spectators feel the same way I do: I think I'll just do my own thing and not lose my toenails or my lunch, but hey man, keep it up if that's what gets you out of bed in the morning. And I think that while runners are pretty excited about their own accomplishments, most of them don't look down on the spectators who are not interested in crossing that particular line. Although a few probably do.

I find a parallel here:



OK, so when I saw this I totally laughed out loud. Because, first of all the Onion is generally pretty funny and secondly there is a contingent of moms out there who are quite vocal--sometimes even superior--about their crunchiness and I know that can grate. I personally don't mind if granola types get vocal because it doesn't affect me, and I even admire them for their convictions because I have my own convictions too, some (not all) of which are lumped in with theirs.

Besides, I'm cool with my vaccinations and plastic toys and red dye #40. I don't think that natural birth, any more than shopping at Whole Foods versus Shoppers or co-sleeping versus using a crib, makes a person morally or otherwise superior to someone who uses an epidural or has a C-section. But, having tried the natural, the epidural, and the C-section, all of which involved pain, I preferred one experience to the others.

Despite my almost nonexistent race record, I kind of feel a little bit of empathy for the runner who keeps on doing something that others think is crazy. The main difference being that there aren't many people heckling runners or accusing them of feeling morally superior for their choices.

But childbirth and motherhood are so charged with other emotions, I think that's why people can get up in arms about it, sometimes to the point of unveiled scorn for women who have--or want to have--their babies with midwives at home or otherwise without drugs. When I was pregnant with Theo and told my OB I wanted to try natural childbirth he responded, "There's no need to be a hero." I wish I had asked him, "Why do you care about my reasons or if I want to be a hero or not?" He also told me after my C-section that "vaginal births are overrated" and it didn't occur to me at the time that the veracity of that statement was biologically unverifiable coming from a man. (or even from a woman who hadn't tried both C-section and vaginal, if it's a matter of comparing the two.)

The partner OB's response to me was, "When you come begging for an epidural I'm going to say I told you so." And after I got my epidural...well...she made good on that. Ouch.

I sometimes sense a similarly contemptuous attitude from faceless moms online. I hope if they knew me in real life they wouldn't lump me into the Thinks She's Morally Superior category. Well I guess if they did there's nothing I could do about it and it doesn't especially affect me other than casting a general pall on public opinion of natural childbirth and homebirth, which I find unfortunate.

So to my point: the only thing that I and my 12:00 splits really do have in common with a runner is that although I am happy with my personal approaches both to birth and to running, I know that neither approach makes me better or worse than anyone else. The motivation for anyone to continue through a (needlessly? pointlessly?) painful journey may include a feeling of victory, of checking off items on a list, who knows, maybe even a hint of superiority. But I think that most keep going back for more mainly because in a weird way, despite the pain, it also somehow feels good, not so much to say to others, "I have done it" but, in fact, to do it. And that has nothing to do with anyone else.

13 comments:

  1. Sometimes we do hard things to prove to ourselves that we can do it. What a sense of accomplishment comes at crossing the finish line, of a race or of labor. A coach told me once "There will always be someone faster than you, and always be someone slower." That is true in life all around. That doesn't mean the person faster is better than the person slower, everyone is trying to cross the finish line and reach the same goal. We need to respect each one's abilities and the way they choose to get to the end.
    THere. I'm off my box.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow. all I can say is wow. I had no idea that the OB you had with Theo was THAT ridiculous. No wonder you didn't have the best experience.

    ReplyDelete
  3. OB's can say the most ridiculous things. If men gave birth the whole childbirth industry would be different. Many times the doctor's attitude makes a woman feel like she can't give birth naturally, or that there is no need to, and that becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

    ReplyDelete
  4. That was Jennifer, not Andre!

    ReplyDelete
  5. "you might also like: 'pilgrim' or 'an old-fashioned christmas.' " i laughed at those suggestions.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Enjoyed your thoughts here.

    Sorry you had a thoughtless doctor.
    After my c-section I was told I would always have to have c-sections. I asked a new doctor in a new town what he thought about that and he said 'well if you don't care if your baby dies'. So he was not the right doc.
    I found a different doctor. A woman who had given birth herself, who listened to me and my questions. I really liked her.

    Just keep running your own race, don't worry about everyone else.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I liked that one. Great comparison. And I love how advice-giving we all can be when we have no idea what we're talking about. Before having kids I was a great parent. I also was never going to have a c-section. Funny how experience changes a person. For the better, I think.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I've done epidural and natural. What is important is that I had 4 healthy babies. Each experience had ups and downs. It is not a competition! Keep on with those kids!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I meant to say those really cute kids!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Wouldn't it be great if we all stopped judging each other and assuming that every situation is the same with the same solution? Good post.

    ReplyDelete
  11. My first OB/GYN had pictures of Tom Cruise on the ceiling. Shouldn't there be some kind of personality testing involved with their licensing?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Why Tom Cruise and not Brad Pitt, Kacy? That would be my question to the OB.

    Eliza, I am sorry that you have had such insensitive doctors! Ask David, I have had "Doctor Crushes" on each of my doctors and I think that is why I liked having babies so much- even when it was a c-section!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I loved this post. You really did have some jerky doctors. I guess my issue is the discrepancy between how I want to give birth and how it seems my body wants to give birth. I mean, how does an 8 1/2 lb. baby turn breach during labor? It is as if I went into the race ready and then my body said sorry, no amount of motivation or training will let you run this race. And, I don't even want to think about a 4rth degree tear wihtout an epidural. In the end I find solace in the glory of modern medicine and that I have two healthy boys to hold and mother no matter how they chose to come out.

    I'll still dream about birthing a baby without drugs and maybe next time I'll be able to. I did get to a seven on my own with Carter before we realized he was breach so maybe, just maybe, my body needed to run a few half marathons before it was ready for the full marathon.

    ReplyDelete